The Georgia Bulletin

Sat, Nov 22, 2008


What I Have Seen and Heard - Archbishop Gregory's Weekly Column

Print Issue: December 23, 1999

Georgians Celebrate Catholic-Lutheran Agreement

Photos

BY PRISCILLA GREEAR

Staff Writer

ATLANTA--A week after representatives of the Catholic Church and Lutheran World Federation signed “The Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification” in Augsburg, Germany, Lutherans and Catholics of North Georgia gathered Nov. 7 in Atlanta to celebrate the turn-of-the-century agreement marking a significant step down the long road to Christian unity.

The joint declaration states that Catholics and Lutherans agree justification, or salvation, is a totally free gift of God and cannot be earned by performing good works, but rather, is reflected in good works.

The declaration’s signing held on Oct. 31 in Augsburg, a city chosen for its place in the history of Lutheran-Catholic relations, marked the 482nd anniversary of the Protestant Reformation. The declaration was originally approved in 1998 and an “annex” document was added to it in 1999 to further elaborate on areas of agreement and points that need more clarification.

According to the annex, “Justification is forgiveness of sins and being made righteous, through which God imparts the gift of new life in Christ. By grace alone, in faith in Christ’s saving work and not because of any merit on our part, we are accepted by God and receive the Holy Spirit, who renews our hearts while equipping and calling us to good work.”

Those presiding at the signing in Augsburg included Cardinal Edward I. Cassidy and Bishop Walter Kasper, respectively president and secretary of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, and Lutheran Bishop Christian Krause and Ishmael Noko, respectively president and general secretary of the Lutheran World Federation. The event marked the first time a declaration of this kind has been recognized officially and jointly by the church bodies.

Lutheran and Catholic worshippers filled the Cathedral of Christ the King for the ecumenical prayer service of healing. Archbishop John F. Donoghue and Bishop Ronald Warren of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America-Southeastern Synod presided at the service along with about 75 priests and male and female Lutheran ministers. Archbishop Donoghue welcomed attendees to the celebration of the agreement, which, he said, was brought forth by God’s love.

“It gives me great pleasure this afternoon to welcome all of you here, Catholics and Lutherans united to celebrate with great joy this joint agreement on the Doctrine of Justification which was recently signed.”

Bishop Warren then prayed for the Christian Church. “Renew its worship, empower its witness, heal it. Make visible its unity … so that united in One Body we may together witness to the unity of your love.”

The two bishops then sprinkled holy water throughout the building. Directed by cantor Hamilton Smith, the congregation sang “A Mighty Fortress Is Our God” by Martin Luther and “The Church’s One Foundation.” The first Scripture reading from the Book of Romans focused on achieving righteousness through faith in Christ.

Bishop Emeritus Harold Skillrud, of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America-Southeastern Synod, was present at the service. He was one of about 450 official delegates to witness the signing of the declaration in Augsburg which he helped fashion during the four years he served as co-chairman of the dialogue between Lutherans and Catholics. He shared his experience of working on the agreement with those gathered.

Comparing Germany’s Berlin Wall to the division between Catholics and Protestants, he described how both came down, not through military might, but through God.

“Last Sunday in a small city in Germany just a few 100 kilometers southwest of Berlin in the city of Augsburg, Germany, a 2,000-year-old city, another wall collapsed, a wall that had been built in stages.”

Bishop Skillrud, who chaired the planning committee for the service, spoke of how the Protestant Reformation began when the young Catholic monk, Martin Luther, on Oct. 31, 1517, posted his famous 95 Theses on a church door in Wittenburg. One of his key complaints was that he believed the Catholic Church put too much emphasis on people’s deeds. Justification, or salvation, according to Luther, was a gift of God and could not be earned. The Peace of Augsburg arrangement was made in 1555 where it was determined that the two sides could no longer exist as one body, after which Lutherans and Catholics began to condemn and “to lob shells against each other.”

“Those shells were hurled from both directions,” said the Lutheran bishop.

Worst of all, the churches have had a history of animosity and conflict over the centuries through wars and persecution.

Referring to contentious issues that arose in Luther’s day over justification, he said that many came to believe that their own contrition and satisfaction determined their rejection or forgiveness by God while others sold indulgences, giving the impression that salvation had a price tag. Other misunderstandings and abuses that arose were, for Catholics, that faith is assent and not trust and, for Lutherans, that good works don’t matter.

“No one will deny that even then we were still one family … We are all part of the same family. We have all been nourished by word and sacrament. We have confessed one faith by word in the Apostles Creed and the Nicene Creed.”

Healing began following the Second Vatican Council when dialogue opened up between Lutherans and Catholics that included the crucial issue of justification. Bishop Skillrud said that the agreement hasn’t been brought about by political correctness or compromise, but “has come about because of candles and prayer.”

“The Holy Spirit has worked in his church.”

Yet he also noted that “when we say that there is a oneness among us we first say that we are ashamed (of the lack of unity) and confess before God.”

Bishop Skillrud then recounted the Augsburg celebration filled with hymns and prayers. Following a rainy Saturday, on the glorious Sunday the crowd processed down a cobblestone street from a Catholic cathedral to a Lutheran church.

“What the Holy Spirit has accomplished in this, his church, is nothing more than miraculous.”

“For that entire distance there were lines of people. It looked like the Peachtree Road Race … I couldn’t tell whether they were Lutheran or Roman Catholic because in Augsburg it’s right at 50/50, but I saw many smiles, many smiling faces.”

While the biggest wall has been broken, Bishop Skillrud acknowledged that many other walls of division stand firm. These differences include the number of sacraments both churches practice, church authority, teachings on the Eucharist, the relationship between justice and social ethics and how neither church recognizes the other’s ordained ministry.

Yet there is a will, he concluded, to continue working toward full communion with all Christians who believe in the Triune God. He closed by calling the congregation to share the Gospel so that people may come to know “the Triune God, salvation through Jesus Christ and the wonderful privilege of living out our life in service to him and the God of life eternal.”

Father John Anderson, Catholic representative on the Christian Council of Metropolitan Atlanta and co-ecumenical director of the archdiocese who served on the event’s planning committee, then offered a reflection. Pastor at Prince of Peace Church, Buford, Father Anderson said he was in seminary in Rome while the document was being ironed out. He was able to take a class with Lutheran theologian Dr. Harding Meyer, who worked on the declaration. Meyer had said its beauty is that it emphasizes common ground and that it may be the first time that two mainline denominations agree to disagree on less important issues in a spirit of tolerance. Christian tolerance, Father Anderson said, involves entering into and holding up the other’s burdens and respecting differences while letting go of prejudices, which brings growth and new understanding. With this respect, he said, Lutherans and Catholics may live with increased unity in their diversity, just as Jesus prayed to his disciples that they may all be one.

“We know how much our world needs tolerance, our cities and schools need tolerance, transformed living. Justification comes from transformed living and that’s really what it’s all about to be a follower of Jesus. How will we be transformed in the likeness and the love that is Jesus? How will we find ways to go into our homes, our schools, and witness by work or common witness to transform other communities that have yet to find common ground?”

He said the document won’t do anything if it’s not used to build up God’s kingdom and, in that spirit of unity and tolerance, called Catholics and Lutherans to work together and set a Christian example.

“Together may we contribute to building the church into a living community of hope--realizing differences but also living out of our transformed hearts so that the life of discipleship may be an appealing option that is attractive to everyone.”

Closing the service, Bishop Warren made a petition for unity of the church of God and that all may grow in faith, hope and love.

“Send your blessing upon your church so that what we have begun in this spirit may be brought to completion in your power,” he said.

Archbishop Donoghue then asked that church leaders be enlightened in wisdom and strengthened in faith to build up the Body of Christ. He called attendees to go out and live their prayers as instruments of peace and reconciliation.

Following the prayer service, David Jenkins, executive director of the Christian Council, said that the document is a significant part of the Christian ecumenical movement underway worldwide. The Christian Council works to support all movements toward Christian unity, he said, noting that in addition to doctrinal differences many factors such as race, class and politics divide those within denominations.

“This is one of the many ways that we work towards church unity in the world, a kind of theological, doctrinal agreement, and there are five or six different ways that the church is moving towards unity and this is one … it is terribly important to be here,” he said.

“The credit goes to Archbishop Donoghue, Bishop Warren and Bishop Skillrud for bringing it here together truly to the local congregation right away. It has to get celebrated. There are a number of ways that churches are moving towards unity because we are divided by so many differences, really, and one of the differences is doctrinal.”

FAITH LEADERS -- (L-r) Bishop Emeritus Harold Skillrud, of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America-Southeastern Synod, Atlanta Archbishop John F. Donoghue and Bishop Ronald Warren, Bishop Skillrud’s successor, take part in a Nov. 7 service at the Cathedral of Christ the King, Atlanta, celebrating the joint agreement on the doctrine of justification between Catholics and Lutherans.
Photos by Michael Alexander


LOOKING AHEAD -- Father John Anderson, Catholic representative on the Christian Council of Metropolitan Atlanta, urges Catholics and Lutherans to embrace the document on justification by living transformed Christian lives and working together to witness to Christ.