The Georgia Bulletin

Tue, Oct 7, 2008


What I Have Seen and Heard - Archbishop Gregory's Weekly Column

Print Issue: February 18, 1999

Dying By One's Own Hand

Photos

BY KATHI STEARNS

Staff Writer

FAYETTEVILLE--Edward Hamill was a scholar.

A graduate of the University of Georgia with a degree in political science, he loved learning and memorizing historical and political statistics and facts. Though not an athlete himself, he could recite the career averages of every player in professional baseball, basketball or football. Professionally he worked as a substitute teacher in the Fayette County School System and dreamed of traveling overseas while teaching English as a second language.

Carol and Tom Hamill were very proud of their son. He was a good student. He had a great relationship with his parents, a steady girlfriend, and he had just taken the first step in fulfilling his dream of studying abroad in England.

Nothing and no one warned the Hamills that within a week Ed would drink a case of beers, close himself up in their garage and asphyxiate himself from the carbon monoxide of his truck. And no one warned them of the excruciating questions and pain they would experience as a result. No one warned them they would have to wait for time and a personal touch from the Lord to heal their broken hearts. But, fortunately, someone had assured them their family of faith would help in times of crisis. And it did.

Suicide is the eighth leading cause of death in the U.S. Statistics from the National Center for Health reveal that more Americans die from suicide than from AIDS or homicide. It is known primarily as a male tragedy since men are 4.5 times more likely to kill themselves than women. Every day approximately 81 Americans take their own lives leaving behind approximately 4 million incredulous, grieving survivors looking for some way to bear the loss and live with the pain.

On June 5, l995, Carol and Tom Hamill, their daughter, Ann, and son, Tim, became four of these survivors. It’s still hard to share the story, but Carol says that telling it is part of the healing process and the task of grieving.

Carol, at that time the archdiocesan consultant of adult catechesis, and her husband were returning home from a week-long conference of the National Association of Lay Ministry in Colorado. During their time away, they had talked with their son several times because they were aware that he had an important decision to make about whether or not he would study in England. Midway through the week, Ed informed his parents that he had decided to go to Europe. He had even mailed his check to reserve his spot. Ed knew that his decision would impact his girlfriend of more than three years, but he told his parents he was going to have a talk with her over the weekend. His main concern, however, seemed to be an exam at Georgia State University where he was studying to get his teaching certificate.

“When I talked with him, he was very positive about his decision to go to England,” Carol said. “He knew that being in England would change his relationship with his girlfriend who was in medical school. He told me he didn’t think it was fair to keep her tied up while he was in England. I talked with him for about an hour. We discussed that he was not ending the relationship with her. He was simply changing it. We told him we loved him, and that we would be there for him.”

Carol talked with her son the day after that conversation to see how the talk with his girlfriend had gone. She knew it would likely have been a painful conversation for both parties. Ed told her that he had spent eight hours with his girlfriend. He said they both recognized that the change would be painful, but they agreed to try it. He told his mother he was going to focus on the exam that was scheduled five days later.

It was only a day later that the Hamills came home from their conference. They had tried to reach their son on the phone that afternoon before they boarded their plane. However, since there was no answer, they assumed he was at Georgia State studying for his exam.

Upon arriving at the house, Carol and her husband pulled into the driveway but found the garage closed. Tom parked and began to unload luggage while Carol opened the garage. When she did, she smelled the odor of carbon monoxide and found her son’s truck running.

At first, Carol said she thought her son might have left the truck running while he ran upstairs to pick up one last thing before he left to study at Georgia State. She turned the car off and walked back toward the garage door. Out of the corner of her eye she saw her son propped up against it.

“I saw him there and yelled ‘Ed, get up!’” she said. “I kept saying that to him over and over. My head knew he was gone, but my heart wasn’t willing to accept it. I was afraid to touch him because I knew if I touched him, I would know that he was dead.”

Carol screamed for her husband, who was still taking luggage into the house, to come into the garage. The first thing Tom did was to shake his son. When he did not move, he poured cold water on Ed to see if he could get any kind of response. Again there was none.

Carol had run into the house to call 911. Before the paramedics arrived, the couple began CPR on their son. As the police arrived they secured the area and confiscated a trash can as evidence to determine if Ed had left a suicide note. They found hundreds of pieces of a note from Ed which they reconstructed to find the answer to their question.

Because the suicide note had been torn up into little pieces the police stated that Ed had tried to change his mind about taking his life. This was also evidenced by the fact that he was found near the door of the garage, away from, and not in, the running car. The amount of alcohol Ed consumed likely impeded his ability to remove himself from the garage.

“He looked as if he had sat down to rest,” Carol said. “He looked so peaceful.”

The EMTs worked on Ed for a good while, trying to breath life back into him. They finally gave up in the face of no response.

Carol said she was still unable to accept the reality that her son had actually taken his life. When she saw the EMTs stop working on her son, she asked if he was going to be okay.

“The EMT told me Ed was gone,” Carol said. “At that moment I remember gasping and inhaling deeply but never exhaling. I let out a scream and felt a wrenching pain in my abdomen where I had carried my son. I honestly believed that if I let myself cry, I would die, myself, in my own tears,” she said.

“That night, when my husband and I discovered our lifeless son in our garage, it was as if our blood stopped running and our hearts stopped beating,” Carol continued. “There had been no warning signs. Life simply stopped. Time stood still.”

Carol called her children, her sister, Janet, Father John Koziol, OFM Conv., Carol’s spiritual director and parochial vicar at St. Philip Benizi Church, Jonesboro, and Sister Loretta McCarthy, SBS, a member of Carol’s spiritual support group at the Maisha House of Prayer.

Upon receiving Carol’s call Sister McCarthy and Father Koziol rushed to the Hamill house. Father Koziol anointed Ed before he was removed from the garage.

“During this most painful and tragic moment, the process of seeing my son, who had already left this world, anointed gave me a sense of peace,” she said. “In the midst of a pain that was indescribable, I was able to feel the presence of the whole church and the communion of saints surround me.”

The next few days were a blur to the Hamills. Others took over and carried them along. Surrounded by family and friends, members of the archdiocesan Office of Education, the parish family at St. Philip Benizi and members of Tom’s Baptist church fellowship, the couple laid their son to rest.

“If ever the church was church for me, it was then,” Carol said. “These people were the arms of Christ that carried us. Tom and I and our remaining children were literally embraced the whole week. We never felt alone.”

During the wake, which was led by Tom’s minister, Carol said they were able to begin releasing the blame they felt.

The minister told the story of Lazarus and recalled Martha’s words, “If only you had been here my brother would not have died.”

He encouraged the family not to deal with the “What ifs,” but rather with the reality of the situation and what could be and will be with God. He told them that the “What ifs” in life keep them bound and in the tomb and would choke life out of them rather than be life giving.

“The fact was our son was gone,” Carol said. “My husband and I couldn’t ‘What if’ and ‘If only’ ourselves and survive this loss with any hope or expectation of ever really living again. We realized that we had been the best parents we had known how to be. We loved our son and we supported him. We believed that God had already accepted Ed, and now we needed to accept life as it was. But we also knew that acceptance would take a very long time.”

Carol said that despite the fact her love for her son was unchanged, she was angry at his decision to end his life.

“I was angry with Ed and felt betrayed by what he did,” she said. “In the depths of my soul I could feel his confusion about all the decisions and changes he was facing and the fear that was behind them. The fact that my son had tried to stop the process of killing himself gave me some sense of peace. But the reality was that what he did, he chose to do to himself. My anger did not diminish my love for him. I have accepted the reality of the situation, but I will never accept his choice.”

There is a special sting to suicide that is unique among deaths, experts say.

“It is the unfairness of the situation,” Carol said.

For two years after Ed’s death, Carol said she was emotionally and spiritually paralyzed. It was during this time that she believes her faith community and her church carried her.

“Though I tried to believe that someday I would feel a degree of peace and comfort again, I just couldn’t trust that life would ever be good again,” she said. “I knew in the deepest part of me that Mary and Jesus were both with me during these painful times, and yet that knowledge was something I didn’t really want because I would rather have had my son alive and with me again.”

Time helps natural healing but people have to cope during the time of reeling and pain.

“In my darkest moments I kept remembering a phrase Corrie Ten Boom, a concentration camp survivor, said in The Hiding Place. ‘No pit is so deep that God is not yet deeper,’” Carol recalled. “‘God is not at the bottom of the pit. He is the bottom.’ I knew I was never alone in my pain.”

Carol tried to attend a Survivors of Suicide Group to see if the support group could help her deal with her pain and anger. Initially after three sessions she was so overwhelmed she did not return.

And then Christ himself touched her and renewed her.

A year and a half ago, while attending the funeral of one of Ed’s friends who had died suddenly at the age of 27, Carol said she finally was able to begin exhaling the breath that she took on that day beside the garage when the paramedics stopped working on her son.

“I realized at that moment that I did not need God to carry me anymore,” she said. “I needed God to hold my hand. My heart had finally begun the journey of catching up with my head. I started to cry, knowing that if I cried, I could stop without totally dissolving.”

After awhile many people on the outside believe the grieving process has ended. But for the family members, the process does not end. It just gets a little easier day by day. Recently Carol has had the strength to return to the Survivors of Suicide Group that had overwhelmed her three years ago.

“Ever so slowly I have come to realize that life is easier now and hope and laughter are beginning to be a part of my life once again,” she said. “Now I can feel not only the pain of loss, but also the promise of hope.”

Edward Hamill


IN ED’S ROOM -- Tom and Carol Hamill sit in their late son’s bedroom with some of his momentos. Ed loved baseball and the Bulldogs of the University of Georgia, where he graduated in 1993 with a bachelor’s degree in political science.
Photo by Michael Alexander


FAMILY PORTRAIT -- (Clockwise) In a 1990 family portrait, Carol, her husband Tom, their late son Ed, daughter Ann, and younger son Timothy are pictured.


SPIRITUAL SUPPORT -- Carol Hamill, right, meets with Father John Koziol, OFM Conv., parochial vicar at St. Philip Benizi Church, Jonesboro, once a month for spiritual direction, which helps her through the grieving process.
Photo by Michael Alexander